In this episode we cover:
- 04:26 The problems with current treatments
- 08:03 The underlying issues with IBS-C
- 11:12 The connection between SIBO and rosacea
- 12:25 The drawbacks to Xifaxan/rifaximin
- 15:48 How Atrantil works
- 21:08 Studies published on Atrantil
- 25:36 Clinical pearls for treating with Atrantil
Chris Kresser: Hey, everybody, it’s Chris Kresser. Welcome to another episode of Revolution Health Radio. This week, I’m going to be talking with Dr. Kenneth Brown. He received his medical degree from the University of Nebraska Medical School and completed his fellowship in gastroenterology in San Antonio, Texas. He’s a board-certified gastroenterologist and has been in practice for the past 15 years with the clinical focus on inflammatory bowel disease and irritable bowel syndrome, or IBS. For the past 10 years, he’s been doing clinical research for various pharmacologic companies. It was during these years that he saw the unmet need for something natural that could help his IBS patients. He had been working on a development of Atrantil for the past six years and officially launched Atrantil one year ago. He developed this product with the intent of helping those suffering from the symptoms of IBS, which we now know are caused by bacterial overgrowth.
So, I reached out to Dr. Brown because we started to use Atrantil in our practice, at California Center for Functional Medicine, and had some good results with it, and there definitely is a lack of SIBO natural treatments that are effective and safe to use over the long term in general, but particularly for methane-predominant SIBO and also for constipation-predominant IBS. And when I learned about Atrantil and Dr. Brown’s work here and the research he has done on it so far, I wanted have him on the show to talk about it further. So without further ado, let’s dive in.
Chris Kresser: Dr. Brown, thanks so much for joining us. It’s a pleasure to have you here.
Dr. Kenneth Brown: Oh, Chris, thank you so much for having me on your show.
Chris Kresser: So I thought we could just start up with a little bit about your background and what led you into research on SIBO and IBS, particularly constipation-predominant IBS.
Dr. Brown: Yeah, so I’m actually a practicing gastroenterologist in the Dallas, Texas, area, and I’ve been doing clinical research for the last 10 years as well. This all kind of started when we were doing research for Salix at the time, on Xifaxan, and I think you’ve had, Dr. Pimentel was a guest on your show, and that’s when he and I came in contact and we were trying to help fill their study, and that’s when he noted that SIBO would be a really big problem, and it’s a very exciting time to be involved with it. He demonstrated with rat models at that time the difficulty it would be to get rid of bloating and constipation in all those people that actually have nothing, and the way that they were going really was not going to work with just the Xifaxan. So it was literally 10 years ago where I was like, “Wow!” So if we could figure out the methane aspect of this, we would really be onto something really cool and that’s initially where all the ideas kind of started.
The Problems with Current Treatments
Chris Kresser: Great. So, I’m going to step back just for my listeners who aren’t as familiar with all the terms we’re throwing around here, but many of you have been listening to the show for a while and know about SIBO, small intestinal bacterial overgrowth. You know that the small intestine normally shouldn’t have much bacteria, but occasionally it will become overgrown with bacteria, and that bacteria can produce hydrogen or some of the species of organisms which can produce methane. So, when you have SIBO, you can have a SIBO that’s hydrogen predominant, meaning you have mostly bacteria that are producing hydrogen, or you can have SIBO that is methane predominant, where you have mostly organisms that are producing methane gas, or you can have both, and they tend to present with different symptoms and they require different treatments. And so, part of the challenge here has been that the most effective treatment has been rifaximin [brand name Xifaxan], which is a drug that’s used to treat primarily hydrogen-predominant SIBO, and I think, if I remember off the top of my head, the efficacy of rifaximin for treating methane-predominant SIBO is only about 40 to 45 percent used, when it’s used alone. Does that match with your recollection, Dr. Brown?
Dr. Brown: Well, I think it’s a little bit less than that, actually. In their target studies that they just got published, they are 41 percent for the diarrhea predominant, which is how they got their FDA approval, and so we know that it’s a little bit less or significantly less when used alone for methane.
Chris Kresser: Wow. Yeah, that’s not very effective at all.
Dr. Brown: Yeah, so that’s actually why I’m treating all these people and they’re so frustrated. As a gastroenterologist, I’m frustrated. As a patient, they’re frustrated, and that’s why we really started doing some of the research on this.
A promising treatment for SIBO and IBS-C
Chris Kresser: So, let’s talk a little bit about some of the other treatments for IBS-C and why they are lacking and why they haven’t been effective, because people are typically—a conventional gastroenterologist isn’t even necessarily prescribing rifaximin, they’re using other medications as a first line for this, right?
Dr. Brown: Correct. So, I see a lot of people that tend to fail other things, and one of the biggest issues is that almost everything out there is some form of laxative. Everybody’s focusing on colon, and you’re way ahead of the curve that already realizing that there’s a lot going on in the small bowel but needs to be addressed. But a lot of times, people say, “Oh, you’re bloated and constipated. Here, take this …” And so there’s lubiprostone, which is Amitiza. We’ve got Linzess out there. There’s a new one called Plecanatide, which is coming out. These all can help people go to the restroom, but they still feel very bloated and distended and have an “uncomfortableness,” so they get very frustrated with that.
Chris Kresser: And they’re not really addressing the underlying cause of the problem, which is perhaps the biggest issue.
Dr. Brown: Correct. That’s the biggest thing. It’s that it’s just putting a Band-Aid on it and that’s why they get so frustrated and really start looking for alternative treatments.
Chris Kresser: I think there are even drugs for IBS-C in the past that had to be pulled because of severe side effect. I’m thinking, was Zelnorm one of those or—
Dr. Brown: Zelnorm was, and it was a good drug. We liked it. When it worked, it worked really well. And in fact, not to get off topic, that was when Pimentel first looked at Xifaxan. He was treating people with Xifaxan during the day and Zelnorm at night. That was his regimen because it worked as a phase III contractant. So yes, drugs have been pulled off because of that. When Zelnorm was there, it worked only 10 percent better than placebo, but when it did, it worked well.
Chris Kresser: Hmm-mm.
Dr. Brown: And that’s also one of the drawbacks that these products that are out there are really only slightly better than placebo and some of them can cause a ton of money.
The Underlying Issues of IBS-C
Chris Kresser: Right, right. Okay. So, we have a situation where the currently available treatments have been inadequate because they’re not addressing the cause or when they’re attempting to address the cause with rifaximin, they’re just not very effective at doing that when the cause is methane and the symptom is constipation rather than hydrogen and diarrhea, as is the case with IBS-D. So, let’s step back a little bit more and talk about the underlying causes of IBS-C. So if someone has IBS, they have constipation, the conventional paradigm, they’re labeled with this diagnosis, which basically just describes their symptoms, but there’s rarely any investigation into what’s actually happening under the hood, so to speak.
So you mentioned SIBO, but what about disruptive gut microbiome in general? Have you found that that’s an issue for these patients?
Dr. Brown: I think there’s so much overlap with this and what happens is, is that if somebody comes in and they go see a doctor and they end up maybe seeing even a specialist, like a gastroenterologist like myself, they get an endoscopy, colonoscopy, blood work. It’s normal and unfortunately, a lot of people get sort of patted on the head and said, “Oh well, you have IBS,” and the problem is, is that’s kind of a trashcan diagnosis. Really, anybody that has abdominal pain, if they got a change in bowel habits, then you qualify as having IBS. And once you get labeled, I think a lot of times doctors stop thinking about what else could be going on, and that’s where some of the functional approaches come in. What I tell my patients is that I do see a lot of people that actually improve when we do treat them with Atrantil, and what I tell them is, is that it’s possible that either you had an infection, took antibiotics, even went through a stressful situation and something shocks your small intestine. When that happens, bacteria can start to grow in that area. Then, every time you eat, specifically, starchy foods, then the bacteria will break down the food before you can and then that results in all the bloating and discomfort.
Now, the interesting thing is, I’m starting to see this very close link to where you’re going right here, which is the disruption of the microbiome. We now know that even a lot of research is showing that we’re having an overall inflammatory process that happens in the body. You can call it “leaky gut” if you want, you can call it “intestinal permeability.” Whatever you want to label it, we do know that people feel miserable beyond their intestines and that’s where—once you address that, and I said, “Look, it’s not in your head. We don’t just pat you on the head and say this. I really think that this could be going on and this could be leading to these symptoms, not only in your intestines but throughout your whole body.
Chris Kresser: Yeah. And that’s why there’s such high comorbidity with IBS and depression, anxiety, all kinds of other health conditions. It’s not because it’s just in their head, it’s that low-grade inflammation that’s happening in the gut that’s affecting it as you would expect it to every part of the body.
The Connection between SIBO and Rosacea
Dr. Brown: Exactly. I mean, we’re seeing people—and you’ve probably had the same results in the practice of functional medicine, people that have skin issues, once you treat them, certainly if you treat them from their intestines, their skin gets better. People that have restless leg, pelvic floor syndrome, all these other what we’re calling “trashcan diagnoses,” I’m seeing a lot of my patient gets better after we treat them.
Chris Kresser: Yeah. It’s really fascinating. I don’t know if you saw this, a recent follow-up from an original study that was done showing 100 percent correlation between acne rosacea and SIBO patients, and then they follow them for several years and found that 100 percent of people who successfully eliminated SIBO had a significant improvement in their rosacea. So, it wasn’t just an association, they actually were able to prove causality there, which is pretty amazing.
Dr. Brown: Yeah. I’ve had patients who have been to multiple dermatologists, and I had one patient that was so sweet. She drove in from Austin, which is four hours away just to let me know that she’d suffered from rosacea for about eight years, and after treating her SIBO with Atrantil, that went away and she drove in to tell me so that I could let other dermatologists know. I thought that was fascinating.
The Drawbacks to Xifaxan/Rifaximin
Chris Kresser: Yeah. So let’s talk a little bit more about rifaximin, which is the drug of choice for SIBO typically at this point, and one of the issues that we’ve already covered is that it’s not very effective for methane-predominant SIBO. But there are some issues too, like costs and insurance coverage and recurrence. Can you talk about those a little bit?
Dr. Brown: Sure. So, let’s look at the target studies. We just got Xifaxan approved by the FDA to treat IBS-D. In those studies, really, it was 41 percent effectiveness versus overall versus 31 percent. So we get a 10 percent than placebo. In defense of that in my practice, when I use it on the right person, my results are a little bit better in the IBS-D population. There is still almost 60 percent recurrence rate with these people, so they’re going to come back in and then you did mention that it is very expensive. If you don’t have insurance, it’s essentially cost prohibitive. If you do have insurance, it still can be extremely expensive with copays and such. So the problem is that … okay, let’s back up and talk a little bit, you had mentioned at the very, very beginning you’re telling your listeners about methane production. The issue and the problem that makes it hard to treat SIBO in the first thing is the location of it. It happens to be in the small bowel, but it happens to be intraluminal or inside the intestines, so a lot of the medications we’ve used in the past, metronidazole, sulfa drugs, things like that, those get absorbed so you have this system effect and little effect in the intestines. So Xifaxan, at least, is poorly absorbed, so it does seem to work in the right area, so the first problem is that. Now, the problem that Xifaxan runs into, is that the type of organism that’s actually producing the methane is called an archaebacteria. These are known as methanogens, and they’re actually really cool in the sense that they’re very old organisms. They’re in their own kingdom. They sort of constitute a domain in a kingdom of microorganisms where they don’t even have any cell nucleus or other membrane-bound things like other bacteria.
Chris Kresser: Right. They’re not bacteria, they’re not yeast (just to fill people in here) and they’re in their own place here taxonomically.
Dr. Brown: Yeah, so it’s interesting in that our modern-day antibiotics work in a way that does not affect archaebacteria. So let’s look at Xifaxan, for instance. Xifaxan actually works by binding to the bacterial RNA polymerase so that it doesn’t let the bacteria produce protein. So I think there was a paper that came out not too long ago where they talked about increased efficacy using guar gum plus Xifaxan.
Chris Kresser: Yeah, yes.
Dr. Brown: And that’s kind of interesting in the sense that the bacteria, the more active they were, the more they were absorbing both the guar gum and the Xifaxan because the Xifaxan had to be gobbled up.
Chris Kresser: Right. Dr. Pimentel put it, “You gotta feed ’em to kill ’em.”
Dr. Brown: Yeah. So that’s one of the things about archaebacteria is that it’s not going to do that. And so the exciting thing and one of the reasons why we developed this is that we don’t need the archaebacteria to be eating a whole lot because the way that the quebracho works and the conker tree is that it actually disrupts the methane production of it and it weakens the wall of the archaebacteria.
Like what you’re reading? Get my free newsletter, recipes, eBooks, product recommendations, and more!
How Atrantil Works
Chris Kresser: Cool. I mean, this is a good segue, let’s talk about Atrantil, and I’m glad that you pronounced it because now I know I was pronouncing it completely incorrectly in the intro.
Dr. Brown: Don’t worry. Even my patients that love it mispronounce it, I keep telling them, it’s like, “Ah, my belly feels better.”
Chris Kresser: Right. Okay. Great. So yeah, tell us a little more about how this fills the gap. You already mentioned two of the ingredients, but let’s start it with what’s in this and then what it does that other treatments are not doing right now.
Dr. Brown: So, what we developed is very specifically for this, and so the key to Atrantil is that the molecules work together and they stay intraluminal, meaning, they don’t really get absorbed or they’re very poorly absorbed. So the first ingredient is M. balsamea, which is actually peppermint leaf, so a very, very small amount of it. But we wanted to use the actual leaf instead of the oil because it has polyphenols in it, and the polyphenols are those molecules that are good for you that we find in the Mediterranean diet and such. That calms the area down and then it allows the other two ingredients to do their job. The second ingredient is something you probably never heard of and it’s called quebracho colorado, and what that is, is that it’s a very large flavonoid, which also is a polyphenol, and that comes through the intestine, and what it does is it actually soaks up the hydrogen and absorbs gas, and what’s that going to do is that’s going to starve the archaebacteria. And then it happens to be from the bark of a very old tree that actually has natural defense against fungus and archaeal species, which is why we chose that particular molecule, and so what it does is, as it comes with contact with archaeal species, it weakens the wall. Then the third ingredient, the conker tree, which is known as a saponin, does two things. It actually kills—it’s bactericidal, meaning it kills bacteria—but it very specifically can shut off the enzymatic production of methane from the archaeal species. So to sum it up, we got one ingredient that calms the area, the second one starves the achaebacteria, and the third one shuts off the methane production.
Chris Kresser: Makes sense given the pathology of SIBO and IBS, and you’ve done, I think, two papers on this. There it is, Atrantil. If only we have video, people could see that. You published a couple of research on this, with the second one very recently published—which I read, thanks for sending that. One thing, before we dive into the specifics of that, it stuck out in the second paper was that some researchers have suggested that people with IBS have a quality of life that is lower than people with type 2 diabetes and even end-stage kidney failure. I found that actually easy to believe having a lot of experience with IBS patients myself. It didn’t surprise me and yet it’s pretty remarkable when it’s phrased that way.
Dr. Brown: I try and reassure my patients. A lot of them come in and they feel embarrassed of the fact that they were told they have a functional disease yet they’re still miserable. And when we compare it to these other disease processes that sound very bad—CHF, congestive heart failure, arthritis, things like that, you can modify your life to adapt to that disease. The problem is, your intestines, once they’re in control, you can’t will it to not have diarrhea or to not bloat, to not pain. So it tends to own you, and that lack of control really wears on you and it’s almost like having chronic pain, and so I really empathize with my patients that have this as I know it’s very real and it’s linked to depression, it’s linked to all of those things.
Chris Kresser: I think it’s the number two cause of missing work too, behind the common cold, so this is definitely a serious problem that really wreaks havoc on people’s lives, and I’ve seen that. I’ve seen patients with just a “simple IBS diagnosis” that have pain 9/10 and have taken several trips to the hospital because they thought they were having appendicitis, when it just turned out to be gas pain or something related to IBS. So it’s definitely … it can be a serious problem.
Dr. Brown: Oh, for sure, not just for the patient but on the overall cost to our healthcare dollars. They’ve estimated that over 30 billion dollars a year are actually attributed to irritable bowel syndrome. This includes the patient going to the emergency room, getting CAT scan after CAT scan, which we know isn’t good getting, other tests done, doctor shopping, having some frustration. You know, we’re seeing this a lot. I think that we have shown that now you can have this post-infectious IBS, which essentially is SIBO. We have a lot of our veterans coming back, 20 percent of those veterans who get sick in a foreign land come back and then they sort of get shuffled around, and we’re now showing that it’s probably bacterial overgrowth and they get very frustrated and that’s a huge cost on the overall healthcare system, and so there’s a lot more than just calling this as a functional disease. This affects people’s lives, it affects people’s work, and everything—their relationships, all of it.
Studies Published on Atrantil
Chris Kresser: So tell us a little bit more about these papers. I think the first one was a clinical trial and the second one was a retrospective analysis.
Dr. Brown: Yes. So we have this brief … little bit of background on how we actually came up with these three ingredients. It’s always something that my patients want to know and it has kind of an interesting story. When we were looking at this, when we were doing research, I was writing on a dry erase board that ultimately methane was the answer and my research manager, Brandy Scott, she actually is a very bright woman. She was an attorney and then got her masters in political science, I said, “Look, Brandy, if we can figure out how to do to this, we could help a lot of these people with severe bloating.” She had been a policy writer for a senator in Iowa, and she went, “Holy cow, wait a minute. Back when I was doing some policy writing, they were trying to mandate how to decrease methane production in cattle.” She’s like, “I got a bunch papers on this on how to do it through food products” and that’s how it all started. So, that’s how we figured out that putting these ingredients would be the best combination on how to decrease methane. So that led to our first trial, which was a randomized trial. We’re just trying to have proof of concept on that, and we did a randomized trial, and that was published in the Journal of Gastroenterology and Hepatology in September 2015, and it was pretty remarkable. We ended up having bloating scores improving almost to 91 percent, constipation improved up to 77 percent, and we didn’t have a whole lot of side effects. So, we knew that we were really onto something really big, and that’s when I decided to put it to the test. As a clinical gastroenterologist, that’s pretty cool that it worked in a randomized trial, but we all know that randomized trials have their pros and cons. I just want to be able to treat these people who are frustrated coming in, so we did a retrospective study—right sort of people, 26 people that had failed everything else available. I mean, the worst of the worst, they had to have failed Amitiza, Linzess, GlycoLax, probiotics, and I’m a big Xifaxan writer, they had to have failed Xifaxan plus neomycin. So we took people that really were at their wits’ end, and shockingly, I gave you that paper there—or not shockingly I should say, that as we expected—they did equally as well. We had almost an 88 percent quality of life improvement. Bloating improved threefold. We had a threefold improvement … I’m sorry, bloating improved fivefold, pain improved threefold, constipation improved three-fold. So, super-exciting in the sense that we felt like, “Wow! Now we finally have something that we can actually help some of these people!”
Chris Kresser: Yeah, that is really exciting, and we’ve been using it in our practice and I’ve seen some good results so far. It’s pretty early in the game for us, so we don’t have as much experience yet, but we have definitely seen some improvement and I like the idea, as a functional medicine guy and someone who’s originally trained as an herbalist, before anything else, I’m definitely interested in botanical medicine, and I’ve seen the trial. There was one trial that compared the botanical protocol for SIBO with rifaximin, where the botanical protocol came out as performed as well or better than rifaximin with fewer side effects. And so, we have these amazing plant medicines available to us; we often forget about them.
Dr. Brown: Exactly, and I think that was the one out of Pittsburgh there. Yeah, I saw that. The only problem with that one was there was no real regimen for which antibiotics combination to use, I mean, herbal antibiotic combination to use. But I love seeing that an academic center is at least trying it and that’s awesome because a lot of times—and I’m just now really kind of getting involved with my functional medicine society down here, I gave a lecture—I really believe that there is some sort of Venn diagram where we can put this all together. Think of IBS and SIBO in one circle, think of leaky gut in the other, and then think of diet in the third, right there in the middle is the sweet spot. And I had so much fun being in a room full of functional medicine doctors where I gave a 45-minute lecture and we ended up with a two-hour Q&A where half of it was me asking them questions and their experience and what they have success with. I really think that we’re heading in the right direction as far as gut health, bringing a lot of gastroenterologists and MDs, speaking with naturopaths, speaking with dieticians because everybody just wants people to get better. That’s the bottom line.
Clinical Pearls for Treating with Atrantil
Chris Kresser: Yeah, absolutely. So, a lot of, about 25 percent of my audience actually, are healthcare practitioners of some sort. So for their benefit and for the patients, I’m curious just to know some clinical pearls that you’ve discovered over the last year or longer. I’m not sure how long you were using it before it came available, but what would you tell patients or clinicians who are treating patients some things to be aware of in terms of Atrantil. Like, did the people typically get better right away, or is there a Herxheimer type reaction in a lot of patients where they get a little bit worse initially and have what some colloquially refer to as a “die-off” reaction? What should patients and clinicians expect in terms of using this treatment?
Dr. Brown: Absolutely great question. I really kind of put these … I put each patient into two different categories. There are the ones that have mild disease or intermittent disease and they’re going to respond a little bit different, and then those are the ones that come to see me. And you probably get this a lot also, patients come to see you that you may be a second opinion person.
Chris Kresser: Yeah.
Dr. Brown: So by the time they come to see me, I’m really dealing with difficult people. So I’m going to start with that group first. What I have found is that depending on the bacterial load, really, we need to hit them hard and strong, just like we did in the original studies with Xifaxan, and that’s how I explain it to them. I said, I want you to do a course of this. I want you to take two capsules three times a day until you start feeling better, and clinically, I can say that now that we’ve been out for a full year, we’ve treated more than 40,000 people with this countrywide. We’re very open about having people contact us, give their experience. So we’ve sold 40,000 units in a little bit more than a year. We know that those people that have very, very tough-to-treat disease are really going to take 10 to 20 days to really start feeling better. So, 80 percent of those people are really going to start noticing that. Of those, I would say, and I warn all my patients about it, so I tell them that if they start feeling bad or start experiencing a die-off, that’s not necessarily a bad thing. I don’t want you stop. I want you to stick through it. I add a little bit of baby aspirin, which tends to help and they can get through it, and so they get very excited when they start to have that because they kind of feel like something’s happening. In my own practice, I never really saw that very much whenever I would treat people with Xifaxan if they have constipation, so that kind of explains why we’re not having that kind of success with that. So, of these people that do that, what I do is I have them take that course, they get through it and then we’re learning something that most of my patients, they taught me this, they just feel better if they sort of take it as a daily supplement. And the reason is, is that these are just polyphenol molecules. They are the molecules that our body really wants and they almost work like prebiotics then. Then, they go into your colon where the colon breaks them down and makes you feel better. So most of my patients do a course and then they just stay on it, and then as needed, go back up. So that’s really tough to treat.
Now, the extreme to treat, it always makes it a tough day when I show up to clinic and somebody’s already holding my product and I’m like, “Oh no, that’s all I had.” Then, we sit down and talk and then we really start going through some different things. And that’s where I have a … I have a great nutritionist that I work with here and she helps me look at it, okay, maybe there’s some food products and things like that, so we do leak testing and things. And as we’re going through it, very surprisingly, I have had some of these patients come back to me and say, “Hey doc, you know what, I increased it to three three times a day and now I’m better.” So we know that there’s the dosing thing. This is a moving target. We’re new, we’re breaking ground, and so just because it doesn’t work, maybe we need to add something else, and I’m talking about the bell curve here way to the right, people that just are struggling with everything. I have treated people with both Xifaxan and Atrantil, I’ve tried putting people on erythromycin at night, and you know, I can maybe get another 10 percent out of it. And so as the type of doctor I am, I tend to just focus on those ones that don’t do well and I almost forget about this whole left of the bell curve that does absolutely awesome on an as-needed basis. So from a clinical standpoint, I actually have severe gluten intolerance, and when I take Atrantil with any type of bread products or gluten products, I have zero issues.
Chris Kresser: Interesting.
Dr. Brown: It’s really interesting, and so that is an angle why I have all these patients taking it as needed. The mechanism of action, I don’t know. I don’t know if we’re binding zonulin. I don’t know if it’s the hydrogen sink that works that way, but I actually have celiac patients that swear that they can, and I’m not telling anybody that has celiac to go out and try this, but they’re the ones that actually say, “Yeah, there’s something else going on here,” and so that’s where we kind of where we start thinking of what else is going on, what’s the future of this. But for the clinicians in the audience, it’s two separate groups, main groups: the ones that need to take it periodically and then sort of take it as an overall digestive health; the ones that need a good round of treatment, 10 to 20 days, sometimes a little bit longer, and then that little subset that I’m going to … well, basically, people like you and myself are trying to figure out, right? Those people that keep getting second opinions and that’s what I really like, when I get feedback from people and they say, “Hey, I took it with barberry and I had a better response.” “Oh, that’s awesome.” We’re trying to figure those stuff out.
Chris Kresser: Yeah. Makes sense. Are there any typical symptoms in terms of a die-off reaction that, is there anything that’s typical, like, worsening of constipation or even diarrhea or gas or bloating, or does it just kind of run the gamut?
Dr. Brown: I think it runs the gamut, but they will typically have whatever symptoms I tell them the die-off will cause.
Chris Kresser: That’s the nocebo effect.
Dr. Brown: Yeah.
Chris Kresser: Very well documented, real deal.
Dr. Brown: Yeah. I just want to go as, “If you do have this, it’s a die-off, you may notice some headaches, fever-like, and maybe increased bloating and constipation,” and then for sure it happens. So it’s kind of all over.
Chris Kresser: Yeah.
Dr. Brown: And very interesting, when we first launched one of my patients who was actually on a SIBO form and she said, “Hey, I took this and I got better,” so we jumped right into the most difficult group, great feedback from them. We have 100 percent money back guarantee, I just want to know why. How did you feel? What happened? Because we learn, it’s a learning process. And that particular group that was already on the forum had already failed everything. They kind of whittled themselves down to being really tough people. Those people gave us great feedback on the die-off reaction and what worked and what didn’t. And some of them tried Saccharomyces and that seemed to help a little bit, and some of them took the aspirin, so I love when my patients in the internet community give us feedback. We’re just trying to help people, is the bottom line.
Chris Kresser: Absolutely. So what’s next? Do you have any other research projects going on or things you’re thinking about for the future or just continuing that, kind of, learn more about Atrantil in this approach?
Dr. Brown: Well, I think there are a couple of things. I’ve got my interests, and then of course, we do have still pay the lights to keep manufacturing Atrantil, so we’re actually working with some great doctors at Texas Tech right now and they are putting together a large multicenter study that we’re almost ready to start rolling in and we’re doing that just like it would be for any large pharmacological agent because as we start to bridge this gap between the natural products and pharmacologic products, I want to hold this up to the same standards. So that’s going to be third party. It’ll be done out of Texas Tech, they got some great guys over there. And when we start enrolling, we would love to have you enroll people and everything. Let’s do a large multicenter trial. The reason why it hasn’t been done before—people, whenever I talk, they’re like, “I’d like to see a larger trial.” I’m like, I would like to also except that much of this is just being funded by me and my colleagues—actually, everything is only funded by me and colleagues. You know, everything takes money and that’s why—it’s one of the reasons why we don’t have good studies on probiotics, for instance. Somebody has to foot the bill, and if you want to foot the bill and then risk having your particular probiotic combination not look good, well, you’re out several hundred thousand dollars, you know, so—
Chris Kresser: Yeah. It’s one thing for a pharmaceutical company to shove it in the file drawer, as they say, the file drawer phenomenon. It’s another—
Dr. Brown: Exactly.
Chris Kresser: Because you’re a small company. So, thanks so much for taking the time to be with us, Dr. Brown. I’m really grateful that you took a risk and decided to make this product because I’ve had a similar experience to you where IBS-D and hydrogen-predominant SIBO are a lot easier, more straightforward to treat than methane-predominant SIBO, and so it’s really great to have another tool and arsenal not only for us at the California Center for Functional Medicine but all the clinicians on training in the ADAPT framework program and the future clinicians that I hope to train. So, I appreciate your work in this area.
Dr. Brown: I do want to say one thing, and I appreciate what you’ve done also, the doctor’s tend to try and treat themselves, so I finally went as a patient to a colleague friend who is a functional medicine doctor and he recommended your book.
Chris Kresser: Oh, cool.
Dr. Brown: And this is actually before any of this took place, so I had to laugh, I’m like, okay, so I think that the future of autoimmune disease lies in diet and polyphenols and things like that. And looking over that, I need to order your book, and I’m going to do that and figure out what type of Paleo diet I need to be on.
Chris Kresser: That’s right, cool. Well, thanks again, Dr. Brown. I look forward to more collaboration in the future. Definitely let us know about the new study because we have an enormous number of patients that we have treated and are treating for SIBO, so we would be definitely interested in participating.
Dr. Brown: Absolutely. Thank you so much for your time.
Chris Kresser: All right. Take care.
Dr. Brown: Bye, Chris.
Okay everyone, I hope you enjoyed that interview with Dr. Brown. If you’d like to try Atrantil, you can get it in my online store. As I’ve said, we’ve been using it at the California Center for Functional Medicine and had some really good results with some patients, so I definitely think it’s worth a try, and if it does work well for you, I agree with Dr. Brown that taking a lower maintenance dose over a long period of time or indefinitely, it may not be a bad idea especially because of the really high recurrence rates for SIBO. And studies have shown that it can recur anywhere between 40 and 60 percent and up of patients, depending on their particular presentation, and it’s a real challenge clinically to treat these patients because even when we’re successful in getting rid of SIBO, it’ll often come back. So I think having an option that’s just a simple combination of botanicals that patients can take over a long term rather than multiple courses of very expensive drugs that have potential side effects is a much better option in my opinion.
So again, thanks for listening, I’ll see you next time.
If you’d like to leave a question for me to answer in a future episode, you can do that at chriskresser.com/podcastquestion. You can also leave a suggestion for someone you’d like me to interview there. If you’re in social media, you can follow me at twitter.com/chriskresser or facebook.com/chriskresserlac. I post a lot of articles and research that I do throughout the week there that never make it to the blogger podcast, so it’s a great way to stay abreast of the latest developments. Thanks so much for listening. I’ll talk to you next time.
Better supplementation. Fewer supplements.
Close the nutrient gap to feel and perform your best.
A daily stack of supplements designed to meet your most critical needs.
Why does Dr. Brown recommend aspirin to some of his clients with SIBO?
Dr. Brown recommends aspirin to those that experience a die-off reaction when taking Atrantil to help subside and reduce the duration of those symptoms.
We sell a lot of Atrantil at our retail location in Dallas. Really glad to get this clarification on how to better implement it for better outcomes. We get mostly very positive feedback, especially when they start to see the larger picture of how diet is affecting their disbiosis.
Hello, I am excited to try this new treatment but have a couple questions.
1. I have a hard time swallowing pills due to narrowed esophagus, can I open the pills in water and drink?
2. I take Hydrochloric acid and enzymes with food, can I take Atrantil at the same time?
3.Can I take Atrantil with my other supplements as well?
Thank you for your time!
Reba, I believe they are not answering questions here. You need to access the pruduct site and contact them. I did and got my answer within 24-36 hours.
Thank you both, for this informatve conversation. I’ll pass it on to my MD friends, who are interested and have treated this disorder.
Will Atrantil help IBS -D..And how do I get it
I have SIBO and roseacea and did take Atrantil for a month at full strength (3 bottles = 6 pills per day = 120 dollars) and it worked a bit but sadly, it is too expensive to continue at 120 dollars a month. I am guessing it would need to be continued for at least 6 months at full strength for the harder cases. I have also been to gastroenterologists who refuse to test for SIBO and don’t even help the patient.
One question: are there any out-of-the-box thinking gastroenterologists like Dr. Brown in the Atlanta area? I have certainly looked and found nothing but rigid, old-school docs; hence, winging it on my own with mixed success. Please pass on any recommendations you have!
try Dr, John Thomas in Woodstock GA he is a disciple of Dr, Ben Lynch his website is http://www.ihcog.com
I am so excited to hear about Antrantil and incredibly grateful to doctors and clinicians who are digging deeper on SIBO. I have had three reoccurances even though I do everything I know how, following the protocols to a T and working with doctors and a naturopath. I have just been treated again in August, went through yet another colonoscopy that was normal, and have just ordered Antrantil to try and keep it at bay. Thanks Chris for bringing this to my attention!
When is the best time to take Antranil ? I am currently starting another round of Xifaxan for recurrent SIBO (had it for 5 yrs). Do you take it at the same time or wait until you finish Xifaxan?
I’ve noticed that Atrantil contains Titanium Dioxide which I’ve read can be harmful. I’m wondering what your opinion is on this?
We realize that some people are concerned about the titanium dioxide in Atrantil. There is less than .01% of titanium dioxide in each capsule and there are no definitive studies showing that ingesting very small quantities of this naturally occurring mineral is unsafe. That said, we hear your concerns and we are happy to announce that moving forward Atrantil will be completely titanium dioxide free. Expect the updated Atrantil formula to be available in December.
That’s good to hear. How about the magnesium stearate? It would be great if Atrantil was as pure and trustworthy as the products in the Pure Encapsulations range.
Hey Cat!
Chris has written about magnesium stearate before:
https://chriskresser.com/harmful-or-harmless-magnesium-stearate/
Be sure to read the whole thing, but he concludes the article with:
“Overall, I haven’t found scientific evidence to substantiate the claims against magnesium stearate, and the small amounts found in supplements shouldn’t be a problem for the majority of the population.”
Dear Chris,
First of all, You Rock!
Thanks for doing an interview on this topic. I have had recurring SIBO but never heard before that xifaxan may not work on methane related SIBO cases. I just checked the results of my last SIBO test and it seems like hydrogen levels increase while methane stays the same. Nevertheless, rifaximin, neomycin and some other herbal supplements did not work and I refused to go back on them. I would be willing to try atrantil but I have a question. If my SIBO is more related to hydrogen rather than methane levels, can atrantil still be used for treatment? You mention above that treating hydrogen related SIBO cases with rifaximin etc is more straightforward.
Thank you.
I am longing for info on treating Microscopic Colitis…I have Lymphocytic Colitis , others have Collogenous Colitis…I’m in a wonderful on-line support group, but wonder if you have any thoughts or patients with this often debilitating disease….
Great talk, Chris. Any thoughts / comments on whether this treatment will work on hydrogen sulfide dominant SIBO And UC, or what else might?
Hello Chris and Dr. Brown
I have been searching for answers for a couple of years now. Conventional medicine has not really helped and just frustrates the living hell out of me. The problem I really have is finding a functional medicine practitioner near me or at least someone who will look at the whole picture, not just a part of it. I asked my doc about SIBO and she had never heard of it. Do you have a list of doctors somewhere? It would be a very helpful addition to the site for those of us that live nowhere near you.
Unfortunately, we don’t have a list of physicians to recommend to our community members on hand, but you may want to check out The Paleo Physicians Network or Primal Docs.
I have heard some patients who are very sensitive say that they can’t tolerate the excipient magnesium stearate – can anyone comment on this and whether that would be a caution for some people in using Atantril?
It is so typical of bog standard supplements and other sundry capsules to include useless (for the patient) fillers, binders, anticoagulants etc etc ad infinitum.
As if people haven’t got enough gut problems to contend with.
I have been diagnosed with SIBO and have not had very good luck treating it. I live in Lubbock and would love to be part of the study through Texas Tech if they decide to do that any time soon.
I was just diagnosed with severe methane SIBO — my baseline was more than 50ppm, spiking to over 100 with lactulose. I’ve been trying Atrantil and a HCL supplement for just over a week now. The first 5 days were pretty rough with increased bloating and discomfort, but for the past couple days I’ve felt better than normal. It might be a coincidence, but I’m going to continue with both supplements and hope the improvement lasts. Atrantil is very expensive but as of now I’m mildly optimistic.
Char, how did you progress with the atrantil?
Jose- Lack of air or ‘air hunger’ is a symptom of Babesia, which is a co-infection of Lyme disease. Lyme and co can also wreak havoc on your intestines, muscles, and basically all systems.
Maybe, but not in my case- They believe is a problem on my cervical spine which could be affecting the nerves and creating the problem. Did a seated MRI and today my neurosurgeon they will get the results. Also, when I feel the pressure which is almost all day long when I stand or walk or even talk my anxiety kicks in and I refuse to take a larger dose of anxiety medication just to make me feel 20% better. I take a very small dose of anxiety medication (30% of what my Doctor wants which is low itself) One thing that I repeat to all my Doctors is that when I lay back (flat over my back) to sleep symptoms (all of them) goes away 80%-100% and that is why they believe the problem with my neck and upper back is creating this. Sometimes right away, and sometimes it takes 10-15 minutes. Food doesn’t make any difference nor do I have any diarrhea, constipation, stomach pain, vomit or nausea- Just a little extra gas from behind. ;-(
Hi,
Yes, I’m one of those who took Xifaxan for 14 days and instead of getting better I got worse. My methane went from .08 to .16 so my GI Doc said he actually believes I don’t have SIBO because I only had one symptom so he offer me no option. I got myself a functional Medicine Doc and she couldn’t help me as well but the blood tests did show I have Gluten sensitivity, Celiac gene and MTHFR Mutation so she put me on a grain free diet and FODMAP diet which did not help as well. She also said I had leaky gut based on symptoms. Still on the grain free but I lost to much weight and probably continue the Gluten free but not the grain free. My symptoms are rib-cage/back and chest muscle pain. Pressure on my middle chest under breast bone and lack of air. ( which could be anxiety). Gas and bloating (bloating not all the time). I will try your product but I have a question. My FMD said I need to stay on a grain free diet all my life because of the celiac gene. I’m 56 and ate gluten like crazy (3-6 times daily) and I still did not get he disease, sure I stay on the grain free if is not helping me a all? I see the reason to stay gluten free, but not grain free. Maybe just eat less grains 2-3 times weekly or so. 😉 Btw, my doc’s (GI and Primary) now believe I have a neck problem which could be causing the chest and back pain/pressure so I will see a neurosurgeant in 2 weeks. Any comment and/or suggestion is appreciated.
Correction on my question:
I’m 56 and ate gluten like crazy (3-6 times daily) and I still did not get he disease, should I stay on the grain free if is not helping me a all? I see the reason to stay gluten free, but not grain free. Maybe just eat less grains 2-3 times weekly or so. ?
I have had this for a very long time; severe leaky gut, IBS, sibo, etc, etc. I am gluten, dairy, and soy intolerant so I stay away from those, but Low carb diets make me worse due to the severe adrenal fatigue I have also. The infection of SIBO pulls on the adrenals and weakens them. Low carb can and will make someone worse, so I don’t suggest that at all. I also went through the FODMAP, Ketogenic, Paleo, etc, etc. and the low carb seemed to make my hormonal function worse.
Thank you, I have extreme fatigue as well so I might have the same problem and it for sure got worse when I started this diet.
Do not expect miracle pills (not even the one mentioned in this article). Chronic illness requires deep lifestyle changes, and it can take as long to clear up as it took to build up. It’s not an easy solution.
Regarding grains: I eat rice, which I don’t seem to react at. But I don’t eat ANY other grain or pseudograin. And that helps me a lot. But you know what else helped me even more: eating huge amounts of fruits, vegetables, and yes, beans. Less fat, more veggies. And vegetable juices too, to maximize vitamin intake.
But ultimately, even that is just partial band-aid fixing. For humans to get better, we need to be out of the house, in nature and in the sun, all day. Read my comment above for more on this.
Thank you- I understand, and I can eat a pizza and it won’t make a difference on how I feel. That’s the point, I do not get sick on any food even gluten. Now, I do understand I can’t eat Gluten, but limiting my diet so much (grains) is just making me worse. I lost so much weight and I feel so weak that is just unreal. My main symptoms appear to be something else and not food related. But I see their is not much difference between a regular Doctor and a functional medicine. They both will just leave you hanging if they can’t find an answer. Sure, with a functional medicine you end up losing BIG amounts of cash. She referred me to a chiro which charged me $$$ for 14 therapies saying that my problem could be a vagus nerve issue. Well, after those 14 therapies I feel worse and it was all cash. Now, my 2 GI’s ( one of them from Mayo Clinic Jacksonviille FL), my allergies and primary said all the same thing. If in 4 months on a grain free diet you have not felt any better, why continue? It’s obvious gluten or grain is causing your pains. In 4 months you should have fely at least a little better and not worse.
Oppsss, another correction.
It’s obvious gluten or grain is not causing your pains. In 4 months you should have fely at least a little better and not worse.
I’m not a doctor. But here’s the thing, from the way you reply about limiting your diet too much because of grains, my idea is that you don’t take vitamins in to heal yourself. Grains have NO nutrition in them. The little that they do have, it gets coupled with antinutrients, that STOP the absorption of the said nutrients! And it gets even worse if you, for example, eat a vegetable with bread. Because the vitamins of the vegetable won’t get absorbed either!
Please have a look here, this is what I eat now and I feel much better: https://mypeganlife.wordpress.com/about-peganism/
In your case, I’d also do 3 vegetable juices a day (only a little bit of fruit inside), in addition to what I’d eat.
Also, just because you eat a pizza, and you don’t immediately feel bad does NOT mean that you can eat gluten. All gluten does is overwork the immune system. Then, depending on the genetics of the person, he/she might get celiac, or might get diabetes, or might get thyroid problems, or might get any of the other 200 auto-immune diseases. So if your problem is auto-immune, gluten is part of the problem. And all grains do have gluten, just not the same kind (the immune system can cross-react between them). Rice is the only grain that has much less of its type of gluten (which is not called gluten, but it’s a similar protein), which is ok to consume once a day, as a whole rice (not processed, e.g. as pizza or pasta).
So, stop eating junk food made from grains. Eat more fish, eat A LOT of veggies and fruits. And eat beans (if from cans, make sure you rinse them first). Don’t worry about gas, it will fix itself out after a while. Personally, I eat beans almost daily in order to get about 40 gr of fiber. Most Americans eat about 15 gr a day which is not enough!
Finally and most importantly: I think you should check out your B12 levels. If you have the 677 MTHFR, then it means that you’re having B12 uptake problems. Which can explain why you feel the way you are, and why you’re losing weight. Eating grains and pizzas and extra calories, wont’ fix your problem in that case. You need to fix the problem on its root.
Thanks again! 😉 I have not ate junk food in 4 months and basically eating as you suggested. I do not get sick at all as for stomach issues. My main pain is the chest/upper back and ribs. and basically is activated when I walk and not when I lay down. So basically I have no stomach issues besides a little gas.
Yes, I had everything checked by my functional medicine and came out with slightly low on K2/D3 and Serene. I mean 50 is normal and I had 49 just to give you an example. So I was put on D3 (1000), K2 (100) and Serine 100. I also take B12 (1000) and B-complex- All grain free. I live in Florida so I take 20 minutes of sun every day, Now, I’m Puertorican and not sure f you know we eat rice and beans just about every day. Sure, I have not done that in 4 months. ;-( So just adding those 2 foods to my diet will make me so much better. And eating gluten free bread and not grain free bread will also help as for my weight because I eat bread on everything. Or at least I did before. 😉 I have been dairy free for a year or so but again I have no need to it. Eugenia, thanks for your suggestions, I will look into the site and maybe end like you just adding rice and beans to my diet and maybe gluten free bread.
beans do not work for everyone. I know that many with leaky gut issues cannot tolerate beans or digest them. Healing this seems to be very individualized and what works for one, definitely doesn’t work for another. Honestly, healing terminal cancer naturally is easier than healing SIBO; and I know that for a fact.
Were you doing probiotics as well as the antibiotics? I am currently on doxycycline for 3 months, but I am also doing tons of probiotics and kombucha. It seems to work a little, but I know that doxycycline isn’t the right antibiotic for SIBO.
Hi,
No, she actually said to stop using probiotics because for her that was part of the problem. I started taking probiotics 3 years ago when I took another antibiotics and my belly was getting extremely hard and then I read that antibiotics kills are the bacteria’s good and bad so I needed to replace it with good bacteria which I did and it helped right away. So after 3 years f taking probiotics had to stop using them even with the antibiotic for SIBO which by the way did not help at all. Well, Doctors are not even sure I have SIBO so they offer me no other option. She did put me back on them recently but at a very low dose after she noticed I was not getting any better. In my personal opinion we are all Ginny pigs for now because they are just starting to learn how to deal with this so is all a trial and error for now. 😉 That is why I will try this product once I get a reply from them. This is just a blog so based on what I see they will not answer questions here even if they are selling a products. ;-(
Probiotics NEVER worked for me at all and I was wasting thousands of dollars. The probiotic enemas worked well with the Natren’s brand. However, when the bad bacteria is too great, probiotics just end up feeding into that as well and don’t do much. Now probiotics have started working a bit.
I did take Atrantil for a month at full strength, which is 6 pills per day and 120 $ a month. I did notice small strides toward healing, but 120 a month is a lot of money. I bought atrantil on amazon. If you can afford to take it for 6 months straight, it would probably help.
I wasted $4000 in 4 months and I feel worse, so $120 for 6 months is way cheaper even if it just help a little. Sure, keeping a moderate diet not to extreme will help as well. I have lost 65 pounds and now underweight, so I can’t lose anymore weight. In my opinion, any diet in extreme will not help your overall health.
I wasted thousands of dollars on ignorant naturopathic doctors (integrative, DCs, NDs, etc) and sadly they sucked me dry and are clueless as to how to heal me, so I am back at becoming smarter than ALL of the doctors (not hard to do) and I WILL heal myself. Unfortunately, many people don’t have the excess income to be able to afford these treatments that may help.
I stay on the diet that makes me feel the best, no gluten, no dairy, no soy. I do some carbs (sweet potatoes, some potatoes, veggies) and protein and this is what gives me the most energy. Low carb only makes me worse and not able to get out of bed at all (due to adrenal issues). I have found in my experimentation and research that many people with leaky gut, SIBO, ALSO have adrenal issues because our bodies have been immune compromised for so long that it pulls on the adrenals.
I liked Chris’ talk at the AHS16 about the adrenal fatique myth, I really suggest to see it on youtube.
Yet another clueless doctor who has NEVER had adrenal fatigue. AND he ASSUMES that people are researching on Google. I have an MBA, am an adjunct professor at multiple universities in which I have direct access to every library in the world to research medical and scientific journals. I hope he gets adrenal fatigue one day and then says there is NO such thing. What an idiot!
The only Dr. who is an expert on Adrenal Fatigue is Dr. Lam, who is an MD. His book is the only book on the subject worth a damn.
Yes, I saw a naturopathic as well before the functional medicine and wasted another few hundreds with no improvement. That is why right now their is no clear solution and even when you have the money they can’t help you saying it could take years to see any results; good or bad. My sister is my age and she decided not even try because she can’t pay the cash just to end up like me besides all the limitations I have with my diet (with no improvements). I will try this product which btw is out of stock here so you have to get it from Amazon which for me is free shipping (prime member).
Grains have protein molecules in them that are so close to those found in gluten, that the immune system will react to them , This is called cross reaction. Grains also have phylates in them ( chemicals to protect them) , you can get rid of these by soaking grains or sprouting them, but you still have cross reaction from proteins in them. So it is advisable to give up grains , gluten, nightshades, legumes, nuts, seeds, eggs( these have lectins) dairy ,soy, corn, peanuts, sugar,gluten,eggs ( common allergens and inflammatory foods leading to leaky gut and then to autoimmune disorders)
I eat grains like twice weekly now, no gluten. As for the chest/back/rib-cage pains no improvement, lack of air worse as well. I do believe I took care of the SIBO with Manuka Honey 15+ and the only symptom I had was bloating. I have no stomach pain even without a gall-blatter. I still believe reflux is part of the problem even if my GI said it was not related to my pains because I have very mild reflux.
God Bless!
Jose
A very impressive promotion!
So you have a bit of mint, horse chestnut and another herb selling for 40 bucks a bottle with 60 capsules. A bit overpriced.
Well – A-N-D-R-E-W – maybe you should re-read Chris Kresser’s blog, or listen to Dr. Brown own words again!
What do you mean by “suggesting chemical solution” – like pharma products? Chris says that he has tried what the pharma industry has to offer for the disorders in discussion and they did not work and/or had too many side-effects.
Dr. Brown’s Atatril is “plant-based” and has had at better success rate in his and in Chris Kresser’s praxis! (Ok, even plants are “chemical” based..so what’s your point?)
This could mean a light at the end of the tunnel for many of
their patients and, hence, valuable information! (I’m sure big pharma will “mine” it to put-out their own DRUGS, i.e., “chemical” versions of it.)
Calling the info on Ataril PROMOTION is absurd. Why, because they are “informing” us about it and “selling it?” What about all the other Co. that sell supplements?
And to refer to these affliction (SIBO, etc.) as “life-style problems” is simply ignorant!
I’m happily not afflicted with any of them (and am neither a research scientist nor a MD), but know this much from having followed Chris Kresser’s blogs and his interviews with MD on a variety of health topics: your response is full-of-bull!
And, by the way, Chris is not a MD, in case you have not yet gathered this…he is a “Research Scientist” and works in his praxis with MDs.
Frankly, I think you sound like you’re from the PHARMA INDUSTRY and hired/compensated to throw a monkey wrench into the discussion!
There appear to be a few of these on each “comment section”…we’re learned not to care!
Obviously you are unable to understand grammar.
If you go back and open your eyes you’ll see quotation marks where I was responding to “Eugenia October 15, 2016 at 3:50 pm” who and I quote said (please note use of quote marks)
“Suggesting chemical solutions for a lifestyle problem on this blog, I find it offensive.”
I responded to this quote which was nothing to do with me.
Your knee Jerk reaction is evident in the rest of your diatribe and castigations.